Your search results
realtors in albany ny
realtors in albany ny
realtors in albany ny
realtors in albany ny

When Selling a Home in Spring in Albany, NY, Do You Need to Buy First or Sell First?

Posted by Colin McDonald on November 6, 2025
Home Buying
30 Comments
MF
Written by
Real Estate Agent, McDonald Real Estate Company · View profile →
Quick Summary: A couple in Delmar with two kids needed more space and had identified homes in Bethlehem they wanted. The question was whether to list first or buy first in Albany’s competitive spring market. Contingency offers were being declined. Bridge loans were available but expensive. Here is what the situation actually involved and how they navigated it — including what happened when the timelines converged.

They had been in the Delmar house since 2019. A three-bedroom colonial, two baths, good bones, a backyard the kids had grown into. By spring of this year it was not enough. The kids shared a room, the third bedroom was an office that had become a storage room, and the couple had been doing that calculus that move-up buyers do: what would the house sell for now versus what they paid, and is the math on the next house realistic?

The math was roughly workable. The house was worth about $100,000 more than they had paid. The homes they wanted in Bethlehem — larger, better school district zoning, same commute distance — were running $430,000 to $470,000. They had equity, a good payment history, and a combined income that qualified them for the purchase. The complicating factor was the sequence.

The Problem With the Obvious Answer

The conventional wisdom is: sell first, then buy. It is financially conservative and removes the risk of carrying two mortgages. The problem with that advice in Albany’s current spring market is that it assumes the buying side of the equation will cooperate with the seller’s timeline — and it often does not.

The couple looked at three homes in Bethlehem over two weekends in late March. All three had multiple offers. When they asked their agent about submitting a home-sale contingency — meaning their offer would be contingent on successfully closing their Delmar home first — the response was direct: sellers in that price range with multiple offers were declining contingencies. A contingent offer might not even be reviewed seriously unless the competing field was thin.

This is a specific condition of selling a home in spring in Albany, NY right now. The market for move-up homes in desirable Bethlehem and New Scotland locations has been competitive enough that sellers can afford to wait for clean offers. That leaves move-up buyers with fewer options than the conventional advice assumes.

Three Options They Looked At

The first option was a bridge loan: short-term financing secured against their current home’s equity, used to make a non-contingent offer on the new house. Their lender offered it. The rate was higher than a conventional mortgage — two percentage points above prime — and the origination fee and structure made it expensive for anything beyond a very short bridge period. If they carried it for more than 90 days, the cost became meaningful.

The second was a buy-before-you-sell program through a third-party company that would purchase their Delmar home for a guaranteed price, allowing them to make a cash offer on the Bethlehem house. The guaranteed buyout price was below what the open market would likely bring — the discount was the company’s margin — and the couple decided the lost equity was not worth the convenience unless they were stuck.

The third option was the one they chose: list the Delmar home in late March before finding the Bethlehem house, then move as quickly as possible. List first, shop simultaneously, try to align the closings. Risky in the sense that there would be a period of uncertainty, but less expensive than a bridge loan and less equity-diluting than the buyout program.

What the Timing Actually Looked Like

The Delmar home went on the market in the last week of March. They received three offers in the first four days and accepted one with a 60-day settlement and no inspection contingency waiver — the buyers were pre-approved and serious. That gave the couple 60 days to find and close on a Bethlehem home.

In week three of the process, they made an offer on a four-bedroom colonial in Bethlehem that had been on the market for six days. No competing offers at that point. They offered asking price and requested a 55-day settlement to align the closings. Accepted.

Both closings happened the same day. The couple spent one night in a hotel between them, which they had packed for as a contingency. It was tight — if either transaction had experienced a delay, they would have needed temporary housing — but it worked.

One piece of the strategy that helped: the post on the step-by-step process of selling a home in Albany has a timeline breakdown that is useful for modeling the gap between list date and close. Understanding what is realistic to compress and what is not affects whether simultaneous closings are achievable. A related post covers spring home pricing in Albany for 2026 — relevant context for understanding what offers on the sell side will look like in the current market.

What They Would Have Done Differently

In retrospect, they said they would have started the process two to three weeks earlier — listed in mid-March rather than late March. That extra time would have reduced the compression pressure on both sides. The six-day gap between listing the Delmar home and receiving offers was faster than expected, which was fortunate. In a slightly slower month, the same strategy might have required a 75 or 90-day settlement request on the sell side, which would have given them more runway on the buy side.

The key insight from the experience: selling a home in spring in Albany, NY does not happen in a vacuum. The sell side and buy side are running simultaneously, and the contingency problem means buyers in competitive neighborhoods cannot afford to wait for the sell side to close before making offers. The right approach is to create the conditions where both can happen in the same window — which requires early listing, realistic settlement timelines, and a backup plan for temporary housing if they diverge.

McDonald Real Estate’s seller resources cover the full process from pricing strategy through closing — useful if you are working through the same sequence and want to understand what the timeline pressure actually looks like in the current Capital Region market.

For the broader Capital Region context, see the post-offer walkthrough.

Next steps

For the full walkthrough, read Retirement Communities in Upstate NY: Options, Costs, and Homes for Sale — Colin’s complete guide for Capital Region homeowners. Ready to talk about your specific situation? See our Downsize Home in Albany, NY page or call (518) 505-4977.

See also: how much is my house worth in albany ny — a longer look at the same territory.

More on Albany Home Valuation from McDonald Real Estate

30 thoughts on “When Selling a Home in Spring in Albany, NY, Do You Need to Buy First or Sell First?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

  • Advanced Search

Compare Listings